A trust is supposed to keep a family out of court, so a trust dispute often comes as a shock. Here is what Florida law says about challenging a trust, what a trustee owes the beneficiaries, and what a court can do when something goes wrong.
Challenging whether a trust is valid
A trust, or any amendment or restatement, is void to the extent it was procured by fraud, duress, mistake or undue influence; the rest stays valid (Fla. Stat. §736.0406). Two other grounds come up often:
- Capacity. The capacity required to create, amend or revoke a revocable trust is the same as the capacity required to make a will (Fla. Stat. §736.0601).
- Signing formalities. For a Florida resident's revocable trust, the provisions that take effect at death are invalid unless the trust was signed with the formalities of a Florida will, including two witnesses (Fla. Stat. §736.0403).
The person challenging the trust has the burden of proving the grounds. A revocable trust cannot be contested while the settlor (the person who created it) is alive and able to change it; the contest waits until the trust becomes irrevocable, usually at death (Fla. Stat. §736.0207).
What a trustee owes the beneficiaries
| Duty | What it requires |
|---|---|
| Loyalty (§736.0802) | Administer the trust solely in the beneficiaries' interests. A transaction tainted by the trustee's own interest can be voided by an affected beneficiary. |
| Impartiality (§736.0803) | Treat beneficiaries even-handedly, with due regard for each one's interests. |
| Prudence (§736.0804) | Manage the trust as a prudent person would, with reasonable care, skill and caution. |
| Inform and account (§736.0813) | Send required notices within 60 days after accepting the trust or learning it became irrevocable, give a copy of the trust on reasonable request, and give each qualified beneficiary of an irrevocable trust an accounting at least annually. |
Many trust disputes are about these duties rather than the trust's validity. A beneficiary who has not received an accounting, sees trust property sold to the trustee's relative, or watches one sibling's share favored over another's may have a claim worth examining.
What a court can order
When a trustee breaches a duty, the court can compel the trustee to perform, stop a breach before it happens, order an accounting, appoint a special fiduciary to take over the property, suspend or remove the trustee, cut the trustee's pay, void the trustee's act, or impose a lien or constructive trust to recover property (Fla. Stat. §736.1001).
Money damages, often called a surcharge, are measured this way: the trustee owes the greater of the amount needed to put the trust and its distributions back where they would have been, including lost income and appreciation, or the profit the trustee made from the breach (Fla. Stat. §736.1002).
A settlor, cotrustee or beneficiary may ask the court to remove a trustee for a serious breach of trust, for cotrustees' failure to cooperate, or for unfitness or persistent failure to administer the trust effectively, and the court can protect the trust property while that request is pending (Fla. Stat. §736.0706).
Disputes over what the trust means
When the trust's wording is unclear, a court can be asked to interpret it. When the wording itself is wrong because of a mistake, the court may reform the trust, even if the language is unambiguous, on clear and convincing evidence of what the settlor intended (Fla. Stat. §736.0415). A clause threatening to disinherit anyone who challenges the trust does not prevent these proceedings; it is unenforceable (Fla. Stat. §736.1108).
Deadlines that can end a trust claim
How we handle trust disputes
We represent trustees who need to defend their administration, and beneficiaries who believe a trust is invalid or a trustee has gone wrong. We start with the trust documents, any accountings and notices you have received and their dates, and the history of the trust's assets. Then we tell you what the Trust Code allows, what proof is needed, and whether a demand for an accounting or a negotiated resolution should come before a lawsuit. When a trust dispute is tied to a will or a probate estate, our pages on will contests and estate litigation cover those parts, and trust administration covers the trustee's ordinary job.
We serve families in all 67 Florida counties from our Lakeland office. Contested matters can require hearings in the county where the case is filed, and we discuss what that means for your case at the outset.