Estate disputes are hard because they are about family as much as money. The law still runs on deadlines, and missing one can end a claim regardless of its merits. Here are the common kinds of Florida estate disputes, the deadlines that apply, and how these cases move.
Common estate disputes
Will contests
A challenge to the validity of a will, on grounds such as improper signing, lack of capacity, fraud, duress, mistake or undue influence. Our page on will contests covers the grounds and procedure in detail.
Personal representative misconduct
The personal representative, the person the court appoints to settle the estate, is a fiduciary who must act in the best interests of the estate (Fla. Stat. §733.602). The court may remove one for causes including failing to obey court orders, failing to account for property, wasting or maladministering the estate, a felony conviction, or holding interests that conflict with the estate (Fla. Stat. §733.504). A personal representative who breaches the duty is personally liable for the resulting loss (Fla. Stat. §733.609).
Disputes over who inherits
Questions about heirs (a child from an earlier relationship, an adoption, a missing relative) are decided in a proceeding to determine beneficiaries. A child born or adopted after the will was signed may be entitled to a share as a pretermitted child (Fla. Stat. §732.302).
Surviving spouse claims
A surviving spouse may take an elective share of 30 percent of the elective estate instead of what the will provides (Fla. Stat. §732.2065), and may claim exempt property and homestead rights. Disputes arise over what the elective estate includes and whether the spouse waived these rights before or during the marriage.
Trust, property and accounting disputes
Disputes over a trustee's conduct or a trust's validity follow the Florida Trust Code; see trust litigation. Objections to a personal representative's final accounting or fees are raised against the petition for discharge.
Estate disputes often pull in other areas of law, such as family law, real estate and tax; our guide to the areas of law that overlap with probate explains where each comes in.
Deadlines that decide estate disputes
| Claim | Deadline |
|---|---|
| Object to the will's validity, the venue or the court's jurisdiction | 3 months after the notice of administration is served on you, and in any event by the earlier of final discharge or 1 year after service |
| Surviving spouse's elective share | Earlier of 6 months after the notice of administration is served on the spouse or 2 years after death |
| Petition for exempt property | Later of 4 months after the notice of administration is served or 40 days after related will litigation ends |
| Creditor's claim | Later of 3 months after first publication of the notice to creditors or 30 days after service on that creditor |
| Object to a final accounting or petition for discharge | 30 days after the later of the two is served on you |
| Contest a trust that was revocable at death | Earlier of the general limitations period or 6 months after the trustee sends the trust and the required notice |
| Claim against a trustee on a disclosed matter | 6 months after receiving the trust disclosure document or limitation notice |
If you have received a notice of administration, a notice to creditors or a trust notice, note the date it reached you. Most of these periods run from service, not from the date of death.
How estate litigation moves through the court
Contested probate matters are handled as adversary proceedings. After formal notice, they are conducted much like a civil lawsuit, under the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, with written pleadings, discovery and, if the dispute is not resolved, a trial. Removing or surcharging a personal representative, contesting a will, revoking probate, determining beneficiaries, and elective share and pretermitted share disputes are all adversary proceedings unless the court orders otherwise (Fla. Prob. R. 5.025).
Many disputes can be settled without a trial. Florida lets interested persons change their shares of an estate by a written agreement they all sign, and the personal representative must follow it, subject to creditors' and taxing authorities' rights (Fla. Stat. §733.815). Our guide to resolving disputes among beneficiaries discusses practical ways families get there.
A will or trust clause that threatens to disinherit anyone who challenges it does not stop a challenge in Florida; those clauses are unenforceable (Fla. Stat. §732.517; Fla. Stat. §736.1108).
How we approach an estate dispute
We work with personal representatives defending their administration, and with beneficiaries, heirs and spouses who believe something has gone wrong. In the first conversation we look at where the estate is, which notices have been served and when, and which deadlines are running. Then we tell you plainly what the law allows, what proof the claim needs, and whether a negotiated resolution is realistic before anyone files.
We serve families in all 67 Florida counties from our Lakeland office. Contested matters can require hearings in the county where the estate is open, and we discuss what that means for your case at the outset.