When a parent dies owning a house, the house is often the largest asset and the hardest to divide. Siblings disagree about selling, one heir lives in it, a spouse claims it, or a personal representative wants to sell at a price others think is too low. Here is how Florida law handles those disputes.
What we handle, and what we do not
Our real estate practice is litigation. We represent people in disputes over Florida real property, mainly property connected to an estate, a trust or co-ownership within a family. We do not handle closings, title insurance, purchase or sale contracts, leases, or other real estate transactions. If you need a closing, a real estate transaction lawyer or a title company is the right call.
Common real estate disputes in Florida estates
Co-owners who cannot agree: partition
Heirs often inherit a house together. When a will or deed gives property to two or more people without expressly providing for survivorship, they hold it as tenants in common (Fla. Stat. §689.15). When co-owners cannot agree on whether to keep, rent or sell, any one of them may file a partition action (Fla. Stat. §64.031). If the property cannot be divided without hurting the owners, the court may order it sold at public auction and the money divided by each owner's share (Fla. Stat. §64.071). While the estate is still open, partition for purposes of distribution can be handled inside the probate case (Fla. Prob. R. 5.025).
A court-ordered auction may not bring full market value, so it is usually worth trying a buyout or an agreed sale first. Our guide to probate and joint ownership in Florida explains how the deed's wording changes the picture.
Homestead disputes
Florida's homestead rules override a will. If the owner is survived by a spouse or a minor child, the homestead cannot be left to anyone else, except to the spouse when there is no minor child (Fla. Const. art. X, §4; Fla. Stat. §732.4015). When the homestead passes to a spouse and descendants, the spouse takes a life estate, or may elect within 6 months after the death to take a one-half interest instead (Fla. Stat. §732.401).
Disputes arise over whether the property was really the decedent's homestead, whether a spouse waived homestead rights in a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement (Fla. Stat. §732.702), and who receives what share. Any interested person may ask the probate court to decide homestead status; the court's order names who is entitled to the property and each person's interest (Fla. Prob. R. 5.405).
Sales of estate property
If the will gives the personal representative a power to sell, the personal representative may sell estate real property without a court order. If it does not, including in an estate with no will, the sale needs the court's authorization or confirmation (Fla. Stat. §733.613). Protected homestead is not an estate asset at all, though the personal representative may secure and insure a vacant homestead while its status is decided (Fla. Stat. §733.608). Our guides to the personal representative's right to sell real property and real estate sales and mortgages in probate go into the mechanics.
Heirs who think a sale is wrong, too cheap or self-interested have remedies. A personal representative who breaches the fiduciary duty is liable for the loss, with attorney fees awarded (Fla. Stat. §733.609), and may be removed for wasting the estate or holding conflicting interests (Fla. Stat. §733.504).
Property disputes that start elsewhere in the estate
- Will contests. If the will that leaves the property is set aside, who receives the property changes with it. See will contests.
- Elective share. A surviving spouse may elect 30 percent of the elective estate instead of what the will provides, and the value of real property in the estate can be part of that dispute (Fla. Stat. §732.2065).
- Mortgages and liens. A recorded mortgage or lien survives the 2-year bar on claims against the decedent (Fla. Stat. §733.710), so whoever keeps the property keeps the debt attached to it.
How we handle a real estate dispute
We start with the deed and the title history, the will or trust, and where the estate stands. Then we tell you who owns what under Florida law, what each side can ask a court to do, and whether a buyout, an agreed sale or a negotiated division is realistic before filing. When a case has to be litigated, it may run in the probate court as part of the estate or as a separate civil action, depending on the claim.
We serve families in all 67 Florida counties from our Lakeland office. Some disputes require hearings in the county where the case is filed, and we discuss what that means for your case at the outset.